Arwen-Undomiel.com http://www.arwen-undomiel.com/forum/ |
|
Tolkien stole something? don't think so.. http://www.arwen-undomiel.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=15&t=12605 |
Page 1 of 2 |
Author: | Inwenyárë [ November 24th, 2006, 3:26 pm ] |
Post subject: | Tolkien stole something? don't think so.. |
our geography teacher said Tolkien stole the name Middle-Earth from the Chinese who origianally called themselves middle people. I think it's just a qoincidence. Tolkien certainly didn't steel anything! ![]() |
Author: | ethelfleda [ November 24th, 2006, 3:41 pm ] |
Post subject: | |
tolkien stole a lot of stuff - he borrowed from existing mythology to give his own mythology more weight, and he admitted it (really need to refind that quote). i don't know if tolkien knew about the chinese tradition, but "middle-earth" was also used by medieval europeans and tolkien certainly knew that - the word "middengeard" (translated as middle earth) appears in the lines of anglo-saxon poetry that inspired the voyage of earendil. |
Author: | Nauriel Rochnur [ November 24th, 2006, 5:20 pm ] |
Post subject: | |
Yes. I wouldn't call it steal, though. He just used it for his own purpose. Like Eowyn said, Middengard in Norse mythlogy is translated as Middle Earth. Its the place where mortals live. The name frodo was dirived from a name in the book Beawulf. The Rohirric language is extremely close to Old English. |
Author: | Inwenyárë [ November 25th, 2006, 12:43 pm ] |
Post subject: | |
well, maybe he changed some old things into mythologies of his own. but i wouldn't call it stealing. our teacher did. ![]() |
Author: | Gersemi [ November 27th, 2006, 3:01 am ] |
Post subject: | |
he stole nothing. sure he may have borrowed things and changed them around into his own words, i don't call that really stealing |
Author: | The Nightingale [ November 27th, 2006, 8:02 am ] |
Post subject: | |
Stealing is a form of Fan Fiction. Tolkien did not write Fan Fiction, therefore he did not steal. |
Author: | Inwenyárë [ November 28th, 2006, 11:37 am ] |
Post subject: | |
absolutely true. but remember i didn't say it was stealing. it was my teacher who appears to have [for some reason] something against Tolkien. ![]() ![]() |
Author: | Gersemi [ November 28th, 2006, 9:12 pm ] |
Post subject: | |
exactually! the best you can do is ignore them. what do the Non-Tolkien fans know anyway |
Author: | Aredhel Ar-Feiniel [ December 1st, 2006, 9:55 am ] |
Post subject: | |
Stealing? Stealing would be if one takes something that belongs to a rightful owner. Do we know exactly who wrote these myths and legends? And is it wrong to take the idea of a system of an existant (or once existant) civilization? No! Fantasy is fiction, and therefore, so is myths and legends. Shakespeare used Myths and Legends to write his plays. There would be not even one fantasy author if it weren't for being able to use Myths Legends and ancient ideas. If Tolkien was indeed a thief of ideas and a "stealer" then so is every other fantasy author. |
Author: | Inwenyárë [ December 1st, 2006, 2:07 pm ] |
Post subject: | |
![]() ![]() ![]() |
Author: | Maneth Eruvadhril [ December 1st, 2006, 2:54 pm ] |
Post subject: | |
I wouldn't call it stealing...he most cetainly based cultures, myths and stuff that have existed to create Middle Earth like rohirrim look like Vikings, the Sindarin language sounds like Gaelic and rohirric is very similar to Old English among other things |
Author: | Mistress of Magic [ December 1st, 2006, 3:06 pm ] |
Post subject: | |
hmmm, from what I can remember in geography, the Chinese did call themselves something similar to middle earth, but I think it was more like central nation....the believed that the world <i>literally</i> revolved around their country.... |
Author: | ethelfleda [ December 1st, 2006, 3:21 pm ] |
Post subject: | |
Maneth Eruvadhril wrote: I wouldn't call it stealing...he most cetainly based cultures, myths and stuff that have existed to create Middle Earth
like rohirrim look like Vikings, the Sindarin language sounds like Gaelic and rohirric is very similar to Old English among other things the rohirrim are based on anglo-saxons, not vikings. big difference. fewer horned helmets to start with! ![]() i'm studying anglo-saxon culture as an elective module at uni atm, and almost every work i find something else that tolkien used. for example, this week i realised that the "burg" of "hornburg" comes from the anglo-saxon "burh", which was a fortress built during the reign of king alfred; and tolkien's basic framework for writing about battles comes from the poem "the battle of maldon" (read it if you can). i don't see why people get so touchy about this subject. the fact that tolkien borrowed so heavily isn't a slur on his reputation - it's a nod to his vast knowledge and ability to "mix writings" (as barthes would put it). tolkien deliberately took ideas, names etc from existing mythologies, literature and history and made no attempt to hide his influences, and he did so for a very clear purpose - to write fantasy that feels immediately familiar to the reader and therefore reads like history. okay, so i'll conced that "stealing" probably isn't the best word because of the negative connotations he had, but there's no good trying to down play the extent to which tolkien used existing ideas. |
Author: | Aredhel Ar-Feiniel [ December 1st, 2006, 4:44 pm ] |
Post subject: | |
Eärlinde Elensar wrote: :blink: don't get het up, please ![]() ![]() Oh I'm sorry I didn't mean to sound rude.. ![]() ![]() Mistress of Magic wrote: hmmm, from what I can remember in geography, the Chinese did call themselves something similar to middle earth
It was Middle East.. "East" isn't related to "Earth" anyway so.. yeah. |
Author: | Inwenyárë [ December 3rd, 2006, 7:34 am ] |
Post subject: | |
Quote: Oh I'm sorry I didn't mean to sound rude..
![]() no problem ![]() ![]() |
Author: | Princess of Ithilien [ December 7th, 2006, 10:25 pm ] |
Post subject: | |
Hee-hee. I'm just so proud of how everyone rushes to Tolkien's defense! |
Page 1 of 2 | All times are UTC - 5 hours [ DST ] |
Powered by phpBB © 2000, 2002, 2005, 2007 phpBB Group http://www.phpbb.com/ |