Arwen-Undomiel.com
http://www.arwen-undomiel.com/forum/

Alphabet Avatar Challenge : Round One Voting Topic
http://www.arwen-undomiel.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=29&t=12673		 Page 1 of 2
Author:  Joelle [ November 27th, 2006, 4:00 pm ]
Post subject:  Alphabet Avatar Challenge : Round One Voting Topic
Time to vote! I received entries from five different people. To make this easier, I posted all the entries on my Livejournal, which you will be able to see, I promise. Here's how the voting is going to work:

1. Visit this site to see the entries. They are in tables based on letters.

2. Come back here and post your votes as such:
Quote:
A : 1
B : 2
C : 3

You will be selecting only your favorite of each letter. Make sure you have 25 letters voted for! You won't know which person made what until later.

3. Winners will be based on how many of their icons won. This will be explained in the winner's topic.

*Note: There is no "x" table. Any of these icons have not been posted, for reasons which you will know later.*

Please vote, and enjoy! Oh, and comment on the icons if you wish, but don't feel like you have to.
Author:  Lady Erana [ November 27th, 2006, 4:13 pm ]
Post subject: 
Really great entries, all of them! Here's my vote:

A:5
B:3
C:1
D:1
E:1
F:3
G:2
H:4
I:1
J:5
K:2
L:1
M:2
N:2
O:1
P:1
Q:2
R:1
S:3
T:1
U:2
V:1
W:1
Y:1
Z:5
Author:  Antigone [ November 27th, 2006, 4:24 pm ]
Post subject: 
Way cool entries =)

A:5
B:3
C:3
D:4
E:5
F:2
G:2
H:5
I:3
J:4
K:5
L:4
M:5
N:5
P:5
Q:4
R:4 (like the idea^^)
S:5
T:5
U:1
V:2
W:4
Y:4
Z:5
Author:  Firiel [ November 27th, 2006, 6:28 pm ]
Post subject: 
A: 4--I love how you moved away from blue to give us a different take on this scene
B: 5--one of my favorite scenes and I like the misty feel to it
C: 4--I really like the coloring and the "flatness"
D: 4--Oooh, nice. I like the coloring and the second picture
E: 3--I like seeing someone other than Eowyn for 'E' and this was a loverly graphic. I like the subtlety of the text
F: 5--Beautiful. Interesting cropping and I like the sideways text
G: 3--I like the blurry background with the inset of Gandalf's face.
H: 5--Aww, another favorite scene. And love the inset of Faramir and the overall dreamy feel. :)
I: 4--Very unusual and eyecatching. I like the unity of the text and the graphic
J: 4--Neat cropping, nice text and interesting coloring.
K: 2--This was very neat. I like the way the text looks and also the coloring. :)
L: 4--Very lovely and a nice treatment of the scene. Also unusual--not what you immediately think of for 'L.'
M: 4--Love the cropping and the text and the general feel of this one.
N: 4--Wow, that really makes him look frightening. I like how you stayed away from "Nazgul" but retained that theme. The coloring is also very neat.
O: 2--I like the text and the brush as well as the cropping
P: 2--Nice message, darling Pip, and I like how you framed his face with the text
Q: 4--This one was really difficult, but I liked the text on this one as well as the contrast and coloring.
R: 1--I like how you picked 'ring' but didn't go with The Ring. It's nice and simple and I think the Ring of Barahir is pretty cool.
S: 5--I like the simplicity of it and the details you can see on Sting. The border is nice too.
T: 3--Nice colors and the text really works into the picture
U: 1--I like the slight graininess and the way the text and the picture work together
V: 4--This is really lovely. I like the double image and the text works well with it
W: 3--Great cropping, nice coloring, and lovely text. Great job!
Y: 2--I normally don't really go for Tolkien artwork (other than Alan Lee) but this one caught my eye. Very Yavanna-y and you did a wonderful job putting it together. I like the font and the color you chose for it.
Z: 2--I like the runes--very cool. I also like the distant feel.

Lovely work everyone!
Author:  Johnny's Fan [ November 27th, 2006, 6:29 pm ]
Post subject: 
Did I not send you my W entry Joelle? :blink:
Author:  Pandora [ November 27th, 2006, 6:42 pm ]
Post subject: 
A 5
B 5
C 5
D 2
E 2- beautiful
F 3
G 4
H 5
I 5
J 5
K 4
L 4
M 4
N 5
O 2
P 5
Q 3
R 5
S 5
T 4
U 5
V 1
W 2
X 5
Y 5
Z 5
Author:  Caunion cyn Britannia [ November 27th, 2006, 6:56 pm ]
Post subject: 
A: 4
B: 3
C: 5
D: 3
E: 2
F: 4
G: 5
H: 5
I: 3
J: 5
K: 4
L: 5
M: 3
N: 3
O: 4
P: 3
Q: 3
R: 3
S: 5
T: 5
U: 5
V: 2
W: 3
Y: 4
Z: 5
Author:  tim4x [ November 27th, 2006, 7:34 pm ]
Post subject: 
A:3
B:5
C:5
D:5
E:5
F:5
G:3
H:5
I:4
J:5
K:5
L:3
M:4
N:4
O:5
P:3
Q:3
R:4
S:3
T:5 :lol:
U:5
V:4
W:4
Y:5
Z:5
Author:  Joelle [ November 27th, 2006, 8:43 pm ]
Post subject: 
Johnny's Fan: No, you didn't submit a "w" entry.
Author:  Turwaithiel Rochben [ November 27th, 2006, 9:08 pm ]
Post subject: 
A: 5
B: 2
C: 5
D: 4
E: 3
F: 3
G: 4
H: 5
I: 5
J: 5
K: 3
L: 5
M: 1 (so hard to choose!!!!)
N: 2
O: 2
P: 3
Q: 2
R: 3
S: 2
T: 4
U: 1
V: 2
W: 2
Y: 2
Z: 4

Great job, everyone!!!!
Author:  Riniel Anariel [ November 27th, 2006, 9:30 pm ]
Post subject: 
A: 3
B: 5
C: 3
D: 2
E: 2
F: 5 ( I love this one of faramir!! )
G: 2
H: 5
I: 2
J: 5
k: 3
l: 5
M: 1
N: 5
O: 2
P: 5
Q: 3
R: 1
S: 5
T: 2
U: 5
V: 5
W: 2
Y: 5
Z: 5

This was such a hard choice!!
Author:  Johnny's Fan [ November 27th, 2006, 10:13 pm ]
Post subject: 
Joelle wrote:
Johnny's Fan: No, you didn't submit a "w" entry.


Ah, sorry about that. I must have forgotten it. I take it, it is too late to submit. :guilty:

Image

http://img457.imageshack.us/img457/2687/witch1wo3.png
Author:  Fencing Maiden [ November 27th, 2006, 10:32 pm ]
Post subject: 
*sniffles sadly, and waits for next round*

A: 5 - So original, and great colors!
B: 4 - Aww, Bilbo darling! Once again, creatively original, and great effects! :D
C: 3 - Stunning, absolutely stunning.
D: 3 -Aww! Beautiful warm look. Gives me fuzzies.
E: 1 -I'm partial t simple graphics with emotional themes.
F: 4 -AWESOME! INCREDIBLE! Makes me want to steal the graphic... and the brain of whoever made it. :D
G: 4 -once again, *love* it! To pieces!
H: 3 -Sooo darling cute! His eyes... and the soft glow. Aww.
I: 1 -Like the color in this one too. Yay for drawings!
J: 5 -YES! LOVE THIS ONE! *hugs it close* INCREDIBLE! Genious idea, and beautiful graphic!
k: 4 -Love the shading colors! *drool*
l: 4 -*sniffles happily* Too lovely.
M: 2 -Aww. *hugs* He's my new obsession.
N: 1 -Wowo. Scary. Perfect picture positioning too.
O: 4 -ROFLOL! Definitely catches my fancy! :D
P: 1 -Cuuutie. Like the font!
Q: 2 -Really love the pictures! My favorite elf scene.
R: 3 -Simplicity rules. Especially when its the One Ring.
S: 1 -Yes! Chris Lee! Love it!
T: 5 -ROTFLOL! *keels*
U: 1 -Arwen. *sigh*
V: 4 --Aww! Talk about creative! 'Tis amazing!
W: 1 -Oho, spooky.
Y: 5 -Eeek! Gotta love that face! *pinches it*
Z: 4 -I could totally hang this one on me wall.
Author:  Joelle [ November 28th, 2006, 8:23 am ]
Post subject: 
Well, Johnny's Fan, I would submit your entry, but it is unlikely it could win by now.
Author:  Johnny's Fan [ November 28th, 2006, 11:48 am ]
Post subject: 
Joelle wrote:
Well, Johnny's Fan, I would submit your entry, but it is unlikely it could win by now.


Lol, yeah that's true. :-)
Author:  Elalie [ November 28th, 2006, 12:23 pm ]
Post subject: 
A: 5
B: 3
C: 5
D: 4
E: 3
F: 5
G: 5
H: 5
I: 3
J: 3
K: 4
L: 3
M: 4
N: 5
O: 5
P: 3
Q: 4
R: 3
S: 5
T: 5
U: 2
V: 2
W: 4
Y: 3
Z:1
Page 1 of 2 All times are UTC - 5 hours [ DST ]
Powered by phpBB © 2000, 2002, 2005, 2007 phpBB Group
http://www.phpbb.com/