Elanor wrote:
I liked him in Troy

Not as much as Eric Bana but he was still cool.
Has anyone seen Legends of the Fall? I saw it years ago and he's great it that

My mom absolutely LOVES Brad Pitt in Legends of the Fall. As for me, I'd have to say that while he's good-looking, he's not the most attractive actor that I can think of (...ahem...Christian Bale)
Though I have to admit, he and Angelina Jolie do make a ridiculously attractive couple.