Haldir of Lórien wrote:
I'm pretty sure he was Stoor; he lived by the riverside before he became Gollum. Not so sure about Harfoot. But it's spelled "Sméagol".
Yes but he was quite obviously not broader nor heavier than the hobbits and his fingers where long not broad though the river part I'll grant you is most likely Stoor that is why I said part Harfoot part Stoor. But yes there is in my mind no doubt that there is a large portion of him is Stoor.
Oops thanks I just forgot how to spell it