I loved the Hobbit Extras but I love the LotR ones more.

I think it does seem like there's more for LotR because the features covered different aspects of Film making, like there were the films about Tolkien's work, adapting, sound editing, special effects, music etc etc etc. It was like every different department got their chance to shine.
Whereas with the Hobbit- I'm guessing because there was a much shorter pre-production period there wasn't a lot of focus on the creative process. I liked that there was more time dedicated to the experience of filming, and I felt I got a better sense of how the film was made and the actors experiences. But saying that I still would have loved to see more of the design and concept process, and to hear more from Howard Shore about his music. I think because they've released the Special Edition Soudtracks and Hobbit Chronicles Books, which go into far more detail than the Art of LotR did they've skimped on those areas in the DVD. It's a good money making ploy, but I'm greedy I want more of everything!!!
