Wich do you prefer. And has anyone read the new one? I just finished it last night. SICK! Thats what I call it. But I am not going to give it away.

_________________


Missing Charlie already!

I voted for both! I know how you feel about the book... go and talk on the HP spoiler topic, it'll make you feel better!

_________________
<center>

LotR. Don't like Harry Potter.

_________________
<center></center>
<center>"To die for love, what could be more glorious?"
-Marianne Dashwood</center>
^made by yours truly

I thought the first 3 were ok. My fav was the 4th. At least up untill the end. I didnt like the 5th that much. She went from Kiddy books to dark and dagerous. She is treading on unsafe grounds as far as I am concerned. The last book had a few good things tho. I still love LOTr much more tho.

_________________


Missing Charlie already!

LOTR RULES!!

That is all I have to say
*walks away*

^Lol, I totally agree Elf Lady Alane!

I don't like HP.

_________________

I have nothing against Harry Potter, but I love LotR - the books and the movies - very very very much!!! It's outstanding!!

GO LORD OF THE RINGS!!!!

Er - sorry if I'm being a bit loud!

_________________

^ lol, same here

HP's good, (hopefully I can read the 6th tomorrow *crosses fingers*) but LotR is much, much better.

_________________
<center>
Gun-toting vikings? That's your theory?</center>

I love Lord of the Rings! I dont care for Harry Potter at all. I tried to watch the movies once, but they were kinda boring.

_________________

I like LOTR better

_________________

i like em both the same. however, i tend to like the lotr movies better than the harry potter movies and the harry potter books better than the lotr movies. but i like them all about the same. but if jk rowling keeps making me angry with her books, ill change sides.

_________________

[font=verdana]The Anxiety-Prone Gentlewoman
xoxo, LC
[/font]

I like both though I'm more into LOTR. They books are way better than the movies. Hopefully my opinion stays the same after reading the sixth. Though it will be a while before I get it.

_________________

Avatar by me

It's unfair to compare Harry Potter to Lord of the Rings since they're respected for different things. It's also unfair since this is specifically a Lord of the Rings forum and that many people join the forum because of Lord of the Rings and sometimes they judge Harry Potter to be inferior.

_________________
<center>

THE HALLOWFEST 2010
<a href="http://www.arwen-undomiel.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=20958">information here</a>

</center>

I like LOTR, but Im not really into Harry potter beause its not me and Im sad that Sirius dies. I love history and mythology, not so much into mystrey and sports, or the witchcraft in there and I don't really think its inferior, you have to have a reason why you don't like it...

_________________

Faith isn't the ability to believe long and far into the misty future.
It's simply taking God at His Word and taking the next step Joni Erickson Tada

I like 'em both but I definately prefer LotR . GO LOTR!!!

HP is good too though

_________________
Proud Member of the The Evilishy Nazgûl Alliance for World Domination
{Beri}

I said both the same, but I personally don't think it's comparing apples and apples. The have similar themes, such as the battle of good versus evil but are written for a difference audience. Harry Potter is about teenagers, essentially, and Lord of the Rings is about races that certainly wouldn't call 100 years of age really old.

I don't mind that the Harry Potter books are becoming darker. I don't like it, but it's inevitable and to try to deny that would be weak, especially as it would probably be just a move to please the masses. I think I'm a bit more into LOTR than HP, but I ultimately can't choose one over the other.

_________________
<center>i love
doctor who

support Arwen!
[+~^$#?]</center>